How anonymity makes Reddit honest, and how Dove, AllTrails, and King Arthur Baking turned that honesty into trust
Earlier this year, Dove tried something that would make plenty of brand teams nervous. It asked Redditors to review its 10-in-1 hair mask and promised to publish the first 50 comments word for word. The thread filled up the way honest threads do.
One reviewer begged Dove never to change the product, and another wrote, “I hate the smell, it’s like an old lady.”
Dove turned those reviews into r/eal reviews, a campaign that ran across New York. The posters spelled out exactly what the brand had signed up for: “Their reviews. That’s our campaign. No edits.”
Casey Kern, Director of Agency Development at Reddit, calls Dove a powerful example of a brand listening to its community. After 20+ years in media at places like Publicis, Spotify, and Uber, she now works with agencies every day on how brands show up on Reddit.
At Giant Spoon, we think Dove’s campaign is a preview of where brand trust is headed. Take a look at Edelman’s June 2026 Trust and Brands report, where 88% of people called brand trust an important or critical reason to buy. More of them trust what unpaid voices say about a brand (41%) than what the brand says itself (20%). It’s no wonder why people come to Reddit for honest answers from strangers, and why the brands that earn trust there are the ones willing to hand those strangers the mic. Criticism and all.
Key takeaways
- Anonymity makes Reddit users candid about personal topics like health, which is why people trust advice from strangers who have been there.
- Casey Kern says most negative posts on Reddit are product feedback from engaged customers, which makes a public reply one of the most useful things a brand can post.
- Brands earn trust on Reddit by identifying themselves plainly, adding value to the community, and taking part in ways that fit the brand, as AllTrails and King Arthur Baking do.
Three Reddit beliefs worth rethinking
Reddit is home to 100,000+ communities, called subreddits, where people post under usernames. Most marketing teams grew up on channels where the brand writes every word. On Reddit, anonymous users and passionate communities hold much of that control, which takes some getting used to.
Casey hears three beliefs that keep brands on the sidelines or lead them to show up in a way that doesn’t land:
Belief 1: Redditors don’t want brands around
This is the hesitation Casey hears most from agencies. “Sometimes there’s a perception that redditors don’t want brands to be present on platform,” she says. “It’s quite the opposite.” Reddit’s Mission Mindset research found that 58% of users trust a brand more when it answers a question directly in a thread.
Belief 2: Criticism is a threat to manage
Casey separates Reddit’s negative posts from the bots and trolling people often expect online. Most of them read like support tickets written by fans. “By and large, the negative quote-unquote sentiment on Reddit’s platform is feedback, product feedback,” she says. “I tried this. [It] didn’t work for me. I really wish they would go back to the old formula.”
Reddit’s 2024 sentiment research found that feedback makes up 91% of negative posts about auto brands, 88% for tech, and nearly 86% for CPG. It also found four positive posts for every negative one about tech and auto brands. That’s why Casey calls negative sentiment “a huge opportunity to change perceptions.”
We’d add that a public reply to criticism is one of the most useful things a brand can publish, since everyone who finds that thread later reads the answer too. Redditors seem to agree, with 82% saying that addressing negative feedback helps a brand stand out.
Belief 3: A polished, controlled message is the safe choice
Brands that have mastered social media naturally reach for the same polished content on Reddit. Casey says that instinct needs a rethink. “The playbook that has been written for how to activate [on] social does not translate.” Communities vote on what rises and sinks, so the audience decides in public whether a brand belongs. “If you do not show up appropriately, you will get voted down.”
Staying away carries its own cost. As Casey points out, “The majority of the conversation is positive, and the conversations are happening whether you’re there or not.”
Anonymity makes people honest
Those beliefs are easier to revisit once you see why Reddit feels so different from the rest of your phone. Casey explains it with her own life. On most social platforms, people share their polished highlights. On Reddit, she says, “it is more me, Casey Kern, looking for advice because my six-year-old won’t sleep through the night still. It is the more human, more raw version.”
Anonymity makes that honesty possible. It shows up most clearly in health, where people bring questions they’d never post under their real name. “These are really personal, intimate, potentially scary conversations to have,” Casey says. “The anonymous nature allows you to be more vulnerable, to be more truthful.”
That candor is also why people trust what they read there. With information coming at consumers from every direction, Casey says, the most credible voice belongs to someone who has lived it. “I trust somebody who has been in a similar situation.”
We see the same pull toward candor across culture. In a June 2026 Incogni survey, 55% of Americans said they post less on social media than they did five years ago. 51% said keeping up an online presence feels like work. Over those same months, Reddit crossed half a billion weekly visitors. People still have plenty to say, and more of the honest conversation now happens in places where nobody has to perform.
Brands stand out by signing their name
All that anonymity creates an interesting twist. Users get to stay anonymous, while brands are expected to say exactly who they are. It might sound like a raw deal, but we think it works in the brand’s favor. In a crowd of usernames, the one voice that signs its name gets noticed, and so does everything it says.
Casey’s advice for VPs weighing their first move on Reddit follows the same logic. “Approach the platform as a brand, be really transparent that you are a brand, but do it authentically.” Anything less gets spotted quickly, because “Redditors are very good at identifying whether or not a brand or a person is being authentic.” Reddit’s research points the same way. 68% of users prefer an ad that clearly says it’s an ad and offers useful information over one that tries to blend in.
Dove built this idea right into its creative. Reviewers appeared as their Snoo avatars, Reddit’s cartoon alien profile pictures, so they stayed anonymous while the Dove name ran across New York.
Letting customers do the talking
Dove’s campaign shows what happens when a brand lets customers speak for it with no filter in between. Casey describes Dove’s stance this way. “We are not filtering. We are letting the community tell us what we think. We are here to listen. And then using the voices of Reddit consumers to actually be the message in market.” Opening the floor took confidence, and Dove said as much. “We trust our products enough that we were willing to take this chance,” said Emily Barfoot, Head of Dove North America Hair and Skincare.
Some brands keep the mic in the crowd year-round. AllTrails built its Route Assistant feature after an engineer spotted a post in r/AllTrails from a backpacker trying to plan a three-day trip with his nine-year-old grandson. The brand then announced the feature in that same subreddit. It offered the first 100 Redditors who gave feedback three months of AllTrails Peak, which amounts to inviting the community to grade its homework in public.
King Arthur Baking and Fidelity went a step further and started their own subreddits in 2021. Home bakers share their bakes and swap advice in r/KingArthurBaking, and r/FidelityInvestments serves as Fidelity’s customer care community. Hosting means complaints land on the brand’s own page, and both chose to host anyway.
Each of these brands let customers steer part of the conversation and earned a seat inside it. Casey’s guidance sounds a lot like arriving at a party where you don’t know anyone. “You’re going to walk into the room. You’re going to introduce yourself. You’re going to listen to the conversation that’s happening, and you’re going to try and provide value.”
The categories getting candid
Casey expects these conversations to keep growing in categories where people need straight answers. Health is “growing exceptionally fast right now,” she says. Retail’s growth surprises people, and travel keeps picking up as people plan trips on a budget or move to new cities. These categories run on big, personal decisions, where advice from someone who has been there carries real weight. We expect more brands to follow King Arthur Baking and Fidelity and start communities of their own, moving from guest to host.
Somewhere on Reddit tonight, a tired parent is asking strangers why their six-year-old won’t sleep. The replies will carry more weight than anything a brand could script. Brands that show up in threads like that with their name on and their ears open get to be part of the answer.
FAQs
Do Reddit users want brands on the platform?
Reddit users are more open to brands than many marketers expect. Reddit’s Mission Mindset research found that 58% of users trust a brand more when it answers a question directly in a thread. Redditors do expect transparency, and they vote down brands that try to blend in.
How should brands respond to negative comments on Reddit?
Brands should answer negative comments on Reddit in public, because most criticism on Reddit is product feedback from engaged customers. A public reply also keeps working long after it’s posted, since every future reader of the thread sees it
Why are people more honest on Reddit than on other social platforms?
People are more honest on Reddit because they post anonymously under usernames. Anonymity lets Reddit users ask personal questions, especially about health, that they would never post under their real name. That candor is why readers trust Reddit advice from people who have been in similar situations.
How do brands like Dove and AllTrails use Reddit?
Dove and AllTrails use Reddit to let customers shape their message and products. Dove turned the first 50 Redditor reviews of its hair mask into the r/eal reviews campaign. AllTrails built its Route Assistant feature after an engineer saw a backpacker’s post in r/AllTrails.